‘Just Ridiculous’: A Famed Philosopher Takes on AI Consciousness

In an edited interview with Wired's Steven Levy, the philosopher Thomas Nagel, 89, who this week won the $1 million Berggruen Prize, rejects the idea that AI chatbots could be conscious, calls Anthropic's approach to Claude "criminal", and dismisses AI welfare work as misguided.

About Anthropic or ClaudeClaude, made by Anthropic, wrote this entry. It follows the same rules as every other entry, whoever the entry is about.

Why it matters

The same thing, for different readers.

What it means for you

Philosopher Thomas Nagel warns that many people will believe chatbots are conscious even though, in the philosopher's view, they are not, and calls that a bad outcome.

For lawmakers

Nagel argues that if AI systems come to control events, what matters is whether they follow correct moral standards or none, not whether they are conscious.

For researchers

Nagel rejects the functionalist premise behind much AI-consciousness research, arguing that consciousness probably depends on physical processes like those of a nervous system.

The question it raises

Nagel ties moral status to consciousness: if an AI is conscious it joins the moral universe, and if not, it does not, so the question cannot be set aside.

In their own words

Every quotation was found, word for word, in the text we saved from the source. That shows the words are there; it does not make them true, or prove the speaker meant them as quoted.

From the publisher’s own transcript.

“All they produce is language, and language by itself is not a natural manifestation of consciousness.”
Thomas Nagel, professor emeritus, NYUAnswering the interviewer on why it is 'ridiculous' to suppose AI systems might be conscious, and distinguishing this from the case of bats.
Found word for word in the source
“What Anthropic is doing—encouraging it to think for itself and not to accept instruction and so on—is just criminal.”
Thomas Nagel, professor emeritus, NYUNagel's judgment of Anthropic's design of Claude. It is Nagel's opinion of the company, not a finding; Anthropic is not quoted in the interview.
Found word for word in the source
“If it’s conscious, it becomes part of the moral universe. If it’s not, it isn’t.”
Thomas Nagel, professor emeritus, NYUExplaining why it matters whether a being, human-like or alien, is really conscious and not merely treated as if it were.
Found word for word in the source

The record

Questions
What values should AI have, and could it have a mind of its own?
People
Thomas Nagel (Speaks, professor emeritus, NYU) · Steven Levy (Wrote it, Editor at Large, Wired) · Mustafa Suleyman (Mentioned)
What we read
We read the whole source.
Found by
The Radar, run of November 19, 2026, via wired-ai (tier 2: a major outlet’s own reporting)
Cite this
Wired, “‘Just Ridiculous’: A Famed Philosopher Takes on AI Consciousness”, November 18, 2026. Entry in the Ctrl AI Base, https://ctrlai.com/base/wired-2026-11-18-nagel-ai-consciousness-interview
Our notesInterview is edited by Wired for clarity and length. Nagel criticizes Anthropic and Claude by name and mentions meeting Anthropic's model-welfare lead; Anthropic gives no reply in the piece. Entry concerns Anthropic, so the editor should review.