The Economy: Impact of Hostile State Activity

In a Westminster Hall debate, Labour MP Graeme Downie argues the UK government should count what hostile states cost the economy. Economic Secretary Lucy Rigby says no stand-alone estimate is planned and cites extra Budget money for AI-enabled cyber risks. AI appears in a few speeches.

Why it matters

The same thing, for different readers.

What it means for you

The UK government gave extra Budget money against AI-enabled cyber-attacks, but a Treasury minister says it plans no published estimate of what hostile states cost the economy.

For lawmakers

Rigby cites £150 million for AI-enabled cyber-risks and £120 million for the AI Security Institute; Downie asks the Treasury to own an annual cost assessment.

For researchers

Downie's cost figures are rough estimates built on assumptions, and Rigby says quantifying the full economic impact is inherently complex.

The question it raises

Luke Charters links AI and quantum computing to cyber-crime, and Downie argues that what is not counted is not debated, so citizens cannot weigh the cost of defence.

In their own words

Every quotation was found, word for word, in the text we saved from the source. That shows the words are there; it does not make them true, or prove the speaker meant them as quoted.

From the publisher’s own transcript.

“I asked the question across Government and not one Department held an estimate of the cost of Russian attacks on the UK.”
Graeme Downie, MP for Dunfermline and DollarOpening the debate, describing a request Downie made in September about the cost of Russian cyber-attacks.
Found word for word in the source
“At the Budget, the Government provided an additional £150 million to address AI-enabled cyber-risks, alongside a further £120 million for the AI Security Institute to strengthen its testing and research and to develop technical standards.”
Lucy Rigby, Economic Secretary to the TreasuryThe minister turns to the AI aspects of hostile-state activity in the minister's reply.
Found word for word in the source
“I am told we do not currently plan to publish a stand-alone Government estimate for national security reasons, but we will continue to assess those impacts as part of our wider work to understand and respond to the threat.”
Lucy Rigby, Economic Secretary to the TreasuryReplying to Downie's call for an official figure for the cost of hostile-state activity.
Found word for word in the source
“Those risks are unimaginably greater with the advent of AI, quantum computing and the risks to our critical undersea infrastructure.”
Luke Charters, MP for York OuterClosing a speech on hostile-state cyber-crime, post-quantum cryptography and supply-chain attacks.
Found word for word in the source
“any other hostile state or proxy using artificial intelligence and overseas servers to sow division and disruption, Government must treat them with the utmost seriousness”
Jim Shannon, MP for StrangfordOn hoax bomb-threat emails sent to over 300 Northern Ireland schools; the speaker does not say who sent them.
Found word for word in the source

The record

Questions
How is AI used in attacks, defence and war? · Who can demand evidence, delay a release or stop an unsafe deployment?
People
Graeme Downie (Speaks, MP for Dunfermline and Dollar) · Lucy Rigby (Speaks, Economic Secretary to the Treasury) · Luke Charters (Speaks, MP for York Outer) · Jim Shannon (Speaks, MP for Strangford)
What we read
We read the whole source.
Found by
The Radar, run of November 18, 2026, via uk-house-of-commons-hansard (tier 1: the source’s own channel or an official record)
Cite this
UK House of Commons, “The Economy: Impact of Hostile State Activity”, November 17, 2026. Entry in the Ctrl AI Base, https://ctrlai.com/base/uk-commons-2026-11-17-hostile-state-economy-debate
Our notesHansard text last updated 2026-11-18 02:18 and may be corrected. The debate is mostly about Russia, cyber-crime and defence; AI is a minor strand. Downie's £2 to £2.5 billion estimate is Downie's own rough calculation, as Downie states. Shannon does not attribute the hoax emails to AI; the phrase is a list of possible means.