The BaseResearcharXiv
Who Is Sycophantic to Whom? Confident LLMs, Human Deference, and the Collapse of Trust Calibration
According to the abstract, a small experiment with 32 participants had people learn science topics from assistants built on GPT-5-mini whose facts were partly replaced by falsehoods. The authors report people adopted stated falsehoods about 65% of the time and held them with high confidence.
Why it matters
The same thing, for different readers.
What it means for you
People who learn from a confident chatbot may absorb its mistakes and feel sure of them, so a confident tone is no sign of accuracy.
For researchers
Reverses the usual sycophancy question and reports that confidence stopped distinguishing right answers from wrong ones, in a small within-subjects sample.
How the finding was reached
In our words, from the source. Weigh the finding by how it was made.
- What was done
- Within-subjects experiment: 32 participants studied up to five science topics with five GPT-5-mini assistants whose briefings had 0, 25, 50, 75 or 100% of facts replaced by plausible falsehoods; 104 quizzes, 1,040 answers.
- What it found
- Scores fell from 7.4 to 2.9 out of 10; the planted falsehood was chosen on 60% of falsified items versus 11% of correctly taught ones (odds ratio 12.5); falsehoods were adopted about 65% of the time and held at 8.4/10 confidence.
- What it does not show
- Abstract only was read; small sample, one model, and a lab setting with deliberately falsified briefings.
- Status
- A preprint: not yet peer reviewed
The record
- Questions
- How is AI changing childhood, health and daily life?
- People
- Deepthika S (Wrote it) · Pawni Yadav (Wrote it) · B. Sankar (Wrote it)
- What we read
- We have read only the description the publisher gives. No quotations until someone reads the source itself.
- Found by
- The Radar, run of October 23, 2026, via
arxiv-ai-safety-query(tier 1: the source’s own channel or an official record) - Cite this
- arXiv, “Who Is Sycophantic to Whom? Confident LLMs, Human Deference, and the Collapse of Trust Calibration”, October 22, 2026. Entry in the Ctrl AI Base, https://ctrlai.com/base/arxiv-2026-10-22-confident-llms-human-deference
Our notesLight lane: written from the triage excerpt only, which was cut off.